New Help for Teardowns

Posted on: August 18th, 2008 by National Trust for Historic Preservation 1 Comment

 

As we all watch and wait to see how the slumping economy and struggling housing sector either rebounds or continues to fall, one has to question if teardowns – the demolition of houses for larger replacement homes, often referred to as McMansions -- are likely to continue or even make economic sense in the near future. While the demolition of perfectly good houses doesn’t meet our sustainability goals, the practice has developed a strong foothold in many communities around the country, and in Canada and Australia. As I’ve watched this trend grow into a profitable niche market and, most recently, have seen it slowdown in the last year, I’m not convinced teardowns are finished. If anything, teardowns are likely just on a hiatus and, in many places, continue full steam ahead despite the gloomy national economic outlook.

What this current economy does offer us though is a cooling off period to get a handle on this issue and be proactive before teardowns start up full force again. The ways in which communities are responding to teardowns are diverse in approach and overall effectiveness. So in places like Downers Grove, IL, the community is trying to balance the needs of newcomers while also addressing a reduction in affordable “starter” housing, storm water drainage impacts caused in part due to teardowns, and the overall loss of original community character. In Westport, CT, community leaders are responding to teardowns by increasing the period for a demolition delay from 90 to 180 days. Sometimes efforts are being done on a house-by-house basis, such as in Seattle, where a resident is currently making a last ditch effort to save an intact 1908 Craftsman-style home by moving it out of harms way. And in Raleigh, an organization called Community Scale has formed to advocate for approaches that guide infill construction while also preserving the integrity and diversity of the city’s older neighborhoods.

There’s no single tool out there to solve the problem but rather a combination of strategies works best. Recognizing that most people don’t know where to start or go for best practices, a new online tool has been developed called Teardown Tools on the Web. Created as part of the Teardowns Initiative of the National Trust for Historic Preservation, this tool is intended as an easy-to-share, user-friendly, one-stop-shop highlighting approximately 30 tools and more than 300 examples of best practices being used around the country. Check it out at http://www.preservationnation.org/issues/teardowns/

-Adrian Fine, Director Northeast Field Office, National Trust for Historic Preservation

The National Trust for Historic Preservation works to save America's historic places. Join us today to help protect the places that matter to you.

National Trust for Historic Preservation

National Trust for Historic Preservation

The National Trust for Historic Preservation, a privately funded non-profit organization, works to save America's historic places.

 

Ferris Wheels and Shikinen Sengu: Preservation Wayne looks at the replacement of historic landmarks, and how this can affect their surroundings. While die-hard preservationists may lament over the loss of a historic building, Wayne acknowledges that appropriate rebuilding can enhance the surviving buildings and areas. [Preservation Wayne]

Historic College Hill: Like any other institution of higher learning, UNC-Greensboro is rapidly growing and in need of expanding in order to accommodate. Standing in the way of at least one phase of this expansion is a small residential area named College Hill--a National Register designated neighborhood. [Preservation Greensboro]

The Old House and the Sea: Clinghouse--a century-old mansion built on a rock in  Rhode Island’s Narragansett Bay--has quite a unique history. [New York Times]

10 Myths About Abraham Lincoln: Slaves? Depression? Lovers? President Lincoln's Cottage addresses some of the most widespread rumors surrounding our 16th President. [President Lincoln's Cottage]

Marlan Blackwell's Arkansas House: A fire-damaged property gets an sleek, modern redesign. [ModernTulsa]

The National Trust for Historic Preservation works to save America's historic places. Join us today to help protect the places that matter to you.

Notes from New Orleans: An Alternate Site for the VA?

Posted on: August 13th, 2008 by Walter Gallas

 

The Lindy Boggs hospital sits on part of the land being considered as an alternative site for the VA.

The Lindy Boggs hospital sits on part of the land being considered as an alternative site for the VA.

An alternative site for the VA's new hospital is getting serious scrutiny. A public meeting is set for Monday, August 11 to present information on the Lindy Boggs alternative hospital site and to take comments in compliance with environmental and historic preservation review requirements.

This is an encouraging sign, but of course only another step before final resolution of the question of where the VA will ultimately build. The alternative site is known as the Lindy Boggs site, because of the hospital which stands on part of the land now. The hospital served the Mid-City neighborhood until it was closed after Katrina.

One of the warehouses on the alternative site.

One of the warehouses on the alternative site.

Surrounded by warehouses and non-residential building numbering maybe 20 at the most, the site seems an ideal alterative to the so-called "RPC site," which contains 154 structures, mostly houses, of which 123 are contributing historic buildings in the Mid-City National Register District. The Lindy Boggs site lies outside of the Mid-City NR district.

Another encouraging sign is that the Mid-City Neighborhood Association supports re-establishing a hospital at that site.

The National Trust for Historic Preservation works to save America's historic places. Join us today to help protect the places that matter to you.

Upcoming Green Preservation Programs

Posted on: August 7th, 2008 by Barbara Campagna 2 Comments

 

Frank Lloyd Wright Home & Studio - a National Trust Historic Site in Oak Park, Illinois

Frank Lloyd Wright Home & Studio - a National Trust Historic Site in Oak Park, Illinois

If you’re in Chicago or Louisiana in August or September, you can attend an upcoming event which focuses on sustainability and preservation.

CHICAGO – August 12th, 2008

I will be giving the same presentation twice on Tuesday, August 12th: New Directions for the National Trust: Going Green With Historic Preservation . First, I will give this talk at the Chicago Architecture Foundation’s Sustainable Architecture Lunchtime Series at 12:15 pm. Then at 5:30 I will be presenting it to the AIA Chicago at 5:30pm, where it is called Are Older Buildings Green? I believe that the AIA Chicago presentation is sold out, but there is a waiting list.

LOUISIANA, September 4-5, 2008


The National Center for Preservation Training & Technology (NCPTT), with 5 partners including AIA South Louisiana, are presenting a 2 day workshop in Vermillionville, LA entitled Built for the Bayou: Environmental Adaptations in Design Workshop . The workshop will be exploring environmental adaptations in design in Louisiana's historic Gulf Coast architecture and their application in sustainable renovation. This looks like a really interesting regional approach to this topic. Wish I lived closer!

CHICAGO – September 24-26, 2008

NCSHPO (the National Conference of State Historic Preservation Officers) is presenting a 2 plus day workshop entitled the National Historic Tax Credit Conference at the historic Blackstone Hotel. This conference marks the one time each year that everyone involved in Historic Tax Credits – public agencies, private owners and developers, and nonprofit organizations – assemble to update their knowledge on the rehab tax credits and meet colleagues from around the country. This year special attention will be paid to completing projects using both LEED and the historic tax credit. My colleagues, Patrice Frey and Emily Wadhams and I, will be presenting a session with California SHPO Wayne Donaldson on Thursday afternoon.

The National Trust for Historic Preservation works to save America's historic places. Join us today to help protect the places that matter to you.

Barbara Campagna

Barbara A. Campagna, FAIA, LEED AP BD+C was formerly the Graham Gund Architect of the National Trust in the Stewardship of Historic Sites office. She is currently a sustainability consultant to the National Trust and can be reached at bcampagna@bcampagna.com.

 

The oil spill cleanup in New Orleans continues.

The oil spill cleanup in New Orleans continues.

Traffic on the Mississippi River was started, then stopped, then started again this week as efforts continued to both clean up the massive 400,000 gallon oil spill along 100 miles of the lower Mississippi, but also to raise the barge which held the oil. Latest reports from the Coast Guard investigation indicated that the captain of the tugboat guiding the oil barge wasn’t even on the tugboat at the time of the collision with a tanker. Estimates are that almost 140,000 gallons of spilled oil mixed with water have been collected as of Saturday morning.

Some more figures: over 2,000 people are working the spill, using three tugs, 159 work boats, four barges, 20 skimmers and 13 vacuum trucks. About 155,000 feet of containment boom and absorbent boom are being used.

The levee near the Toulouse Street pier shows the oil damage.

The levee near the Toulouse Street pier shows the oil damage.

Sunday morning, clean-up traffic on the French Quarter riverfront was crowded, showing the intensity of the time-consuming effort. The rip-rap (boulders used to line the earthen levee) near the Toulouse Street pier showed the oil damage as the river level has fallen over the last week.

The National Trust for Historic Preservation works to save America's historic places. Join us today to help protect the places that matter to you.

 

Harley Davidson Museum in Milwaukee. Pentagram Architects

Milwaukee's New Harley-Davidson Museum and the Creation of Public Space: Built within a reclaimed industrial area along the Menomonee River, the design of the Harley-Davidson Museum seeks to "integrate the site back into the city; respect and reflect the site's history; make the water an important recreational element and plan for future development." With these goals in mind, Pentagram Architects have "developed an urban design that essentially restored the area's lost street grid and, by doing this, connected the site to the surrounding city by giving it a scale and 'grain' that felt like a neighborhood within the city." The design of the Museum and its surrounding area offers a public space fit for the street-level rally atmosphere of places like Sturgis—whose weeklong rally begins today—and widespread amongst bike culture. [Wheels: The New York Times Blogs]

Sustainability and Historic Resources: Sustainability is all about using the resources we already have in a smarter, more efficient manner. Did you know that 48% of US greenhouse gas emissions come from the construction, operation and demolition of buildings? Preserving our existing built resources can be an effective way to help with climate control. The city of Boulder, Colorado has recently revised its Green Building code, acknowledging the link between preservation and sustainability. [PreserveNJ]

Montpelier Restoration Update: The "Father of the Constitution's" Orange, Virginia estate continues its restoration project. Included in this update is a video of architectural research director Gardiner Hallock installing rosettes in the Drawing Room, and photos of the recreated "Madison Road" leading up to the mansion. [Montpelier Restoration Updates]

Las Cruces, New Mexico--The Museum of Expensive Mistakes in Downtown Revitalization: Pedestrian Malls, Historic Teardowns, plenty of surface parking lots--common revitalization processes like these have the ability to create a ghost town, rather than a revitalized downtown. Place Economics examines these common mistakes, along with the potential for downtown improvement within the city of Las Cruces, New Mexico [PlaceEconomics]

DVD Landscape Tours Available at Drayton Hall: Drayton Hall in Charleston is offering an exciting new way to engage visitors within their mid-eighteenth century plantation grounds. Using tried and true interpretive methods coupled with new technology that allows visitors to receive audio/visual information on specific areas of the site, historical themes related to the historic site, and the preservation efforts necessary to maintain the grounds. [National Trust Historic Sites Weblog]

The National Trust for Historic Preservation works to save America's historic places. Join us today to help protect the places that matter to you.