[Retro Roadmap] Hinkle's Pharmacy in Columbia, Pa.: Serving Sodas and Snacks Since 1893

Posted on: October 31st, 2013 by Beth Lennon 5 Comments

Hinkle's Pharmacy - Columbia PA - Exterior. Credit: Beth Lennon, RetroRoadmap.com
Hinkle’s -- at the crossing of Locust and Third street since 1893.

On the banks of the Susquehanna River, located halfway between the county seats of Lancaster and York, sits Columbia, Pennsylvania. For centuries an integral hub for transportation, first as a ferry crossing and later as part of the Pennsylvania Railroad, it now is bypassed by traffic speeding along Route 30.

But folks smart enough to get off of the four-lane highway and onto the Lincoln Highway will discover a vibrant corner of the historic downtown at Hinkle’s Pharmacy and Restaurant, serving as the heart of the community for 120 years.

While the business began in the three-story building anchoring the busy intersection, it has expanded from its modest beginnings as a pharmacy with a 10-seat soda fountain. Initially remodeled in the 1950s and most recently in the 1970s, the original soda fountain has been replaced and expanded into a restaurant serving breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

Hinkle's Pharmacy - Columbia PA - Restaurant. Credit: Beth Lennon, RetroRoadmap.com
Don't forget to peek around the corner at the orange tile mosaic depicting the tools of the pharmacy trade.

The booth and counter seating at Hinkle’s has been arranged so the waitresses can reach every seat -- all eighty-five of them -- without ever moving from behind the counter. In addition to being efficient for the servers, this configuration also places customers across from each other for easy conversation, even if you’re not a local.

Hinkle's Pharmacy - Columbia PA - Mr. John Hinkle. Credit: Beth Lennon, RetroRoadmap.com
Fourth-generation owner John Hinkle III.

At one of these counter seats you might just find owner John Hinkle III, eating his lunch while catching up on the Wall Street Journal or greeting customers by name as they come in for a bite to eat or to pick up a prescription.

He’ll be happy to tell you a bit of the history of the pharmacy -- how it was started in 1893 by his great-grandfather and how the lunch counter has become a gathering point for the community, with nary a seat to be found on Sundays after church gets out.

Hinkle's Pharmacy - Columbia PA -  120 Years of Service. Credit: Beth Lennon, RetroRoadmap.com
The 120th anniversary placemats reveal that many of the employees have worked here for 10 years or more. It’s that kind of place.

Trying to decide what to order is a challenge, with the menu choices deep and varied. Vegetarian and gluten free choices are available as a nod to more healthy eating, but if you want to get a real taste of local cuisine your best bet is the Shifter sandwich.

Hinkle's Pharmacy - Columbia PA - Grilled Shifter Sandwich. Credit: Beth Lennon, RetroRoadmap.com
The Shifter -- available on soft white bread -- takes on a new realm of flavor when grilled.

The Shifter is about as local as you can get, having been invented in Columbia during its railroad heyday, and not known about outside the city limits.

A tasty sandwich made with ham, cheese, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato and sweet pickles, this was the preferred quick meal for the railyard workers running the switch engines -- known as “shifters” in Pennsylvania Railroad terminology.  Since it was easier to order a “Shifter” rather than list all the ingredients, the nickname and sandwich live on past the life of the railroad that inspired it.

With the highway diverting most travelers away from Columbia, and mandated  mail-order prescriptions taking a toll on the pharmacy side of the business, Hinkle’s has found another way to remain historic yet relevant in this new century -- by offering gifts and hard-to-find products the chain stores don’t carry.

Hinkle's Pharmacy - Columbia PA - Brylcreem - Wildroot - Vitalis. Credit: Beth Lennon, RetroRoadmap.com
Brylcreem, Wildroot, Vitalis – offering products once thought long gone inspires brand loyalty at Hinkle’s.

So if you find yourself speeding along the highway, remember you may be getting to your destination faster, but you may also be missing a chance to savor some local flavor at Hinkle’s.

Visit Hinkle's Pharmacy

Hinkle's Pharmacy
261 Locust St
Columbia, PA 17512

The National Trust for Historic Preservation works to save America's historic places. Join us today to help protect the places that matter to you.

Beth Lennon

Beth Lennon is the creator of the website RetroRoadmap.com. As "Mod Betty," she delights as the retro travel "hostess with the mostess," scouting out cool vintage places and sharing them with the world.

Pop Culture, Travel

5 Responses

  1. Candi

    October 31, 2013

    Great Review! Hope to see more of Mod Betty’s reviews in the future!

  2. Cliff

    October 31, 2013

    Great review! I very much enjoy the Shifter sandwich from Hinkle’s, everyone should visit that place!

  3. Jerry A. McCoy

    November 1, 2013

    Where is a photo of the most amazing aspect of Hinkle’s…the awesome mid-century tile mosaic mural that is on the outside of the building?

  4. Mod Betty / RetroRoadmap.com

    November 1, 2013

    Jerry – here’s a long distance shot – I couldn’t quite fit it into the piece, but I did note that folks should look out for it in the caption of the restaurant sign.


    And here’s a closeup from my first visit to Hinkle’s a few years ago:


    It’s one of my fave unexpected surprises about the place :-)

    Thanks for reading,

    Mod B

  5. Suzanne McGillicuddy

    November 4, 2013

    Love the Brylcreem and Vitalis photo!

    My 76 year old father-in-law stocks up on Vitalis so that he can fill his suitcase and bring back a year’s supply for his older brother back in Ireland who can’t find it in the old country anymore.

    Mod Betty – you just might remember these two gentlemen. They were the dancing Kerrymen flirting with our girlfriends at my wedding. They do have great hair – maybe Vitalis is onto something :)

    I love these reviews and am so glad that Preservation Nation has discovered the Retro Roadmap!