The Great Gatsby Mansions, Part II: Long Island's Lost Gilded Age Mansions

Posted on: July 3rd, 2013 by Aria Danaparamita 4 Comments

130702_blog_photo_gatsbybeacon1
Beacon Towers. "And as the moon rose higher, the inessential houses began to melt away."
-- F. Scott Fitzgerald, The Great Gatsby

In the afterglow of Baz Luhrmann’s summer adaptation of The Great Gatsby, we looked at some inspirations for the novel's Long Island palaces. Yet many of these grand Gilded Age sites now lie in ruin, while others have been demolished. Here is a look at some of Long Island's lost treasures.

130702_blog_photo_gatsbybeacon2
Beacon Towers. “Most of the big shore places were closed now and there were hardly any lights except the shadowy, moving glow of a ferryboat across the Sound.”

Beacon Towers was often cited as Fitzgerald’s architectural muse. The Gilded Age château once stood on Sands Point, overlooking the North Shore. It was built from 1917 to 1918 for Alva Belmont,  ex-wife of William K. Vanderbilt and then widow of politician Oliver Belmont.

Alva was the kind to summer with her parents in Rhode Island and vacation in Europe. Over her lifetime, she built and owned many mansions; at one point, she owned nine. Beacon Towers was her last built in the U.S. The gleaming, white stucco mansion -- and its 140 rooms -- was a mix of Gothic architecture with designs inspired by Spanish alcázars.

In 1925 Alva closed the castle and retired to France. It was sold to newspaper magnate William Randolph Hearst in 1927, who resold it in 1942. Beacon Towers was demolished three years later. Today, only the garden walls, gate house, and garage remain.

Harbor Hill. The castle-like Clarence Mackay estate in Roslyn, designed by McKim, Mead & White between 1899-1905, was dynamited in 1947.
Harbor Hill. "This is a valley of ashes -- a fantastic farm where ashes grow like wheat into ridges and hills and grotesque gardens."

Another fallen mansion is Harbor Hill. The château held a striking view of Hempstead Harbor. The vast grounds once included Turkish baths, shooting galleries, and a casino.

Financier Clarence H. Mackay and his wife hosted the most grand parties of the Roaring Twenties there. F. Scott and Zelda attended a fête at Harbor Hill in 1923. Mackay would throw his biggest one yet the next year, hosting it in honor of the Prince of Wales. It featured two orchestras, fountains of perfumed water, floating flower arrangements, and an unapologetically large American flag made of lightbulbs atop the roof.

Mackay left Harbor Hill in 1938. His son, without the means to maintain the property, leased the grounds to the US Army Air Corps as the Roslyn Air Force Station.

The house and other buildings fell into disrepair. The mansion was dynamited in 1947.

130702_blog_photo_gatsbyfitzgerald
F. Scott and Zelda Fitzgerald were guests at Harbor Hill and Lands End's famous parties.

One estate recently lost was Lands End, rumored to have inspired the Buchanans’ unhappy home. The Colonial Revival mansion on the tip of Sands Point was sold then demolished just earlier this year. Once host to the likes of Winston Churchill, the Marx Brothers, and the Fitzgeralds themselves, Lands End will now become a multi-million-dollar housing development.

Long Island local Zach Lemle is dedicated to documenting these disappearing treasures.

“The first part of the 20th century was an extravagant time for those in the upper echelons of society,” Lemle says, “but many of the places that were built were more than just party palaces. Along with the gardens and grounds these estates were works of art.”

These mansions stand for a unique moment in American social and cultural history -- and not just for their parties. Not only do they showcase the work of America’s talented architects and landscapists, the mansions’ presence also dictated developments like the Long Island Railroad and highways, Lemle explains.

Today, their existence gives everyone else a chance to experience, if for a fleeting moment, that glittering past.

“There have been far too many demolitions of historic houses on Long Island and the threat is still with us today," Lemle says. "Perhaps, if we can just bring more of these places into the light, then more people will become aware of their significance and we'll stop destroying our past."

Scroll through to see more of Long Island’s Gilded Age mansions, some still standing, others now long extinct.

See other threatened sites in the Long Island area on the Society for the Preservation of Long Island's Antiquities's 2013 list of Endangered Historic Places.

The National Trust for Historic Preservation works to save America's historic places. Join us today to help protect the places that matter to you.

Aria Danaparamita

Aria Danaparamita

Aria Danaparamita, or Mita, is a contributor to the PreservationNation blog and recent graduate of Wesleyan University. She enjoys walks, coffee, and short stories. Follow her odd adventures on Twitter at @mitatweets.

Architecture, Pop Culture, Slideshows

4 Responses

  1. dannywanny

    July 7, 2013

    Unfortunately Americans have little regard for their architectural and cultural heritage. These beautiful relics will be destroyed one by one.

  2. Walley Morse

    July 7, 2013

    always a mystery how in Europe those castles last hundreds of years….were lucky to still have the likes of Biltmore..

  3. Tom Gingles

    July 8, 2013

    I agree. It always seems Americans are so anxious to meet the future that we clear away the past and forget it. We as a people need to learn from and revere our past before it is lost forever.

  4. Linda Kelsey-Jones

    July 29, 2013

    Hello Aria,
    Do you know anything about the mansion in Roslyn Harbor that was owned by Dr. William Hughes, eye surgeon, in the ’50s?
    I spent a lot of time there as a pre-teen.
    Thanks for preserving these memories!
    Linda