Preservation Vacation: What's Next for Idlewild, Michigan's "Black Eden"?

Posted on: December 20th, 2012 by David Robert Weible 3 Comments

Idlewild Michigan Historical Markers Dedication, Yates Township, Lake County. Credit: MI SHPO, Flickr
Idlewild Michigan Historical Markers Dedication, Yates Township, Lake County.

It was known as the Black Eden, and at its height in the 1950s and ‘60s, more than 25,000 African-Americans would travel from Chicago, Detroit, Cleveland, and Indianapolis each summer to visit its 2,700 acres of lakes and western Michigan wilderness for intellectual stimulation, partying, and a sense of community. This was Idlewild.

“If you were a doctor, a lawyer, an entrepreneur, an educator, and you had the income to travel either by train or auto, [Idlewild] was a place that you wanted to be,” says Dr. Ronald Stephens, a professor of 20th-century African-American history and culture at Ohio University and author of the forthcoming book, Idlewild: The Rise, Decline and Rebirth of a Unique African-American Resort Town. “The idea of having that sense of community, independence, and ownership was a really big deal in black America.”

Founded in 1912 by four white couples who saw the need for resorts for the growing African-American middle and upper middle class, Idlewild became a place for intellectual and political interaction among prominent members of the 1920s African-American community, including William Pickens and W.E.B. Du Bois.

But the increasingly rapid growth of the working black middle class after World War II, particularly with the rise of the auto industry in the Midwest, created a shift in the culture of Idlewild.

“By the 1950s and '60s, the crowd that was coming up to Idlewild, though they were educated, had a different idea of vacation,” says Stephens. “They were going up there to have fun and party.”

Performer Jackie Wilson at the Paradise Club. Credit: BJ Alvis
Performer Jackie Wilson at the Paradise Club.

And party they did. Several nightclubs hosted the best African-American entertainers of the day, including Jackie Wilson, T-Bone Walker, and Motown stars like the Four Tops. But more than entertainment, these shows were an opportunity for people to interact with the stars. “There was no way they could have done that in the city of Detroit,” Stephens says.

But by the mid 1960s Idlewild began to experience what would be 30 years of social and economic decline. The opening of previously all-white resorts by the Civil Rights Act of 1964, coupled with the sense by many middle class African-Americans that they had “arrived,” led to large scale abandonment of the once-thriving resort, says Stephens. That decline in popularity eventually opened the door for the growing presence of prostitutes, especially during deer-hunting season; an embarrassing truth exposed to the nation on the Johnny Carson Show on Thanksgiving Day, 1977.

Idlewild Historic Plaque. Credit: Dr. Ronald Stephens

Over the last twenty years, Idlewild has made small steps toward revitalizing itself, including identifying thirty-five historic structures along with recognizing the homes of Joe Louis and Dr. Daniel Hale Williams, America’s first open-heart surgeon.

The state of Michigan has also invested roughly $500 million $5 million in the resort’s leadership, which will partner next year with 10 graduate students from Michigan State University in an effort to create a ten-year strategic plan for the community. According to Hubert Brandon, director of the Idlewild Community Development Corporation, plans for the addition of museums, as well as a conference center and hotel are being considered.

“What we’d like to do is preserve the past but also to take that and move it forward to our future,” says Brandon.

The National Trust for Historic Preservation works to save America's historic places. Join us today to help protect the places that matter to you.

David Robert Weible

David Robert Weible

David Robert Weible is an assistant editor at Preservation magazine. He came to DC from Cleveland, Ohio, where he wrote for Sailing World and Outside magazines.

Pop Culture, Revitalization, Travel

3 Responses

  1. Ronald Stephens

    December 21, 2012

    This is a wonderful article. However, there are some inaccuracies in need of clarification. First, I have some concerns about the statement, “identifying or designating thirty-five historic structures like the homes of Joe Louis and Dr. Daniel Hay Williams, America’s first open-heart surgeon.” While approximately 35 or so historic sites have been identified, only 5 historical markers have been designated. Related to this point, none of these sites include the home of Joe Louis. In addition, the correct spelling of the second individual mentioned is Dr. Daniel Hale Williams, not “Hay.” Another inaccuracy involves the statement that reads: “The state of Michigan has also invested roughly $500 million in the resort’s leadership, which will partner next year with 10 graduate students from Michigan State University in an effort to create a ten-year strategic plan for the community.” For the record, I am not so sure the State of Michigan has invested roughly $500 million dollars in the resort’s leadership. This figure appears to be a bit of a stretch.

  2. Hubert Brandon

    January 2, 2013

    The 500 million dollar figure is NOT accurate. However, Michgan State Universiy has agreed to enter into a partnership with the Idlewild Community Development Corporation to begin the development and implementaion of of a strategic preservation/community development plan beginning in January 2013.

  3. Hubert Brandon

    January 3, 2013

    We at ICDC want to thank David Robert Weible for an excelent and very informative and fine article.During the course of the interviews certain numbers and information were miscommunicated and in no way should reflect negatively on the great work done by him on this piece.